⏰ Musk's OpenAI suit dismissed: the jury faulted his timing

The jury never ruled on whether going for-profit broke OpenAI's founding charter - only on how long Musk waited to challenge it. ⏳

Elon MuskTOO LATEPhoto: Gage Skidmore · CC BY-SA 4.0

Photo: Gage Skidmore, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Desaturated and cropped by MrScandal.

What we know

  • OpenAI was founded in December 2015 as a nonprofit by eleven people, with Elon Musk and Sam Altman as co-chairs, as OpenAI said in its launch announcement.
  • The founding backers committed $1 billion in total; tax filings show OpenAI had received only $133 million in total capital by 2021.
  • Musk resigned from OpenAI's board in 2018, citing a potential conflict of interest with Tesla's self-driving AI work.
  • OpenAI converted its for-profit arm into OpenAI Group PBC on October 28, 2025, after the California and Delaware attorneys general approved the plan.
  • In May 2026, a jury found Musk had waited past the three-year statute of limitations before suing to reverse that conversion.

In December 2015, OpenAI was founded as a nonprofit, with Elon Musk and Sam Altman as co-chairs, the company said in its launch announcement. Its backers committed $1 billion in total. A decade later, Musk sued to undo what it had become.

The pledge

The $1 billion never fully materialized. TechCrunch's analysis of tax filings found OpenAI's nonprofit had collected just $133 million in total from its inception through 2021. OpenAI has said Musk invested less than $45 million; Musk, in a 2023 CNBC interview, put his own contribution "on the order of $50 million." The two figures have never been reconciled.

The resignation

Musk left OpenAI's board in February 2018, in a move OpenAI said would avoid a conflict of interest with Tesla's autonomous-driving work; its blog post said the departure would "eliminate a potential future conflict for Elon." He stayed on as a donor and adviser. He did not keep a seat.

By the numbers

  • 8y 3mfrom first to latest entry on recordFeb 2018 to May 2026, 12 dated entries in the file
  • 8receipts behind this story7 news reports, 1 statement, 2015 to 2026

Counted by MrScandal from the receipts, the Files and our rankings.

The filing

In April 2026, Musk amended his existing lawsuit against OpenAI and Sam Altman, asking the court to unwind the restructuring outright - the move that, the previous October, had converted OpenAI's for-profit arm into OpenAI Group PBC, with the nonprofit, renamed the OpenAI Foundation, holding a 26% stake.

The verdict

He lost. On May 18, 2026, a federal jury in Oakland, California found Musk had waited past the three-year statute of limitations before suing over the restructuring, and Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers adopted the verdict. The timeline settled the lawsuit; it did not settle whether converting a nonprofit built to ensure AGI "benefits all of humanity" into an $850-billion-plus company broke that promise.

What it became

The company Musk tried to unwind kept growing. In late March 2026, weeks before the verdict, OpenAI raised $122 billion at a valuation of over $850 billion, CNBC reported.

Quick quiz · 3 questions

  1. On the record or still rumour?OpenAI's for-profit conversion was approved by the California and Delaware attorneys general, announced October 28, 2025.
  2. On the record or still rumour?Whether OpenAI's restructuring itself violated the nonprofit's founding charter was never decided - the jury ruled on timing, not the merits.
  3. Which year?A magistrate judge ordered Musk to testify in the SEC's probe of his Twitter purchase, per Reuters

More games on the record: Price Tag · Timeline

Earlier on file: Elon Musk liable to Twitter investors; lawyers put it at $2.1B · New York Times v OpenAI: 'billions' sought, fair use claimed · Delaware Supreme Court restores Musk's $56B Tesla pay

The Elon Musk file

Last entry May 18, 2026
  1. Ruled

    A federal jury ruled on May 18, 2026 that Musk's OpenAI breach-of-charitable-trust suit was filed too late, per CNBC. This story

  2. Filed

    Musk amended his OpenAI lawsuit in April 2026 to seek reversal of the 2025 for-profit restructuring, per Ars Technica. This story

  3. Ruled

    A jury found Musk liable for misleading Twitter investors with two tweets; his lawyers said they will appeal, per AP. Elon Musk liable to Twitter investors; lawyers put it at $2.1B

  4. Ruled

    Delaware Supreme Court reverses rescission of the 2018 pay plan and awards $1 in nominal damages. Delaware Supreme Court restores Musk's $56B Tesla pay

  5. Filed

    SEC sued Musk in Washington over a late Twitter stake disclosure; his lawyer said he did nothing wrong, per NYT. Elon Musk liable to Twitter investors; lawyers put it at $2.1B

  6. Ruled

    Chancery Court reaffirms its ruling, rejects the 2024 re-vote as ratification and sets plaintiff's lawyers' fee at $345 million. Delaware Supreme Court restores Musk's $56B Tesla pay

  7. Ruled

    A magistrate judge ordered Musk to testify in the SEC's probe of his Twitter purchase, per Reuters. Elon Musk liable to Twitter investors; lawyers put it at $2.1B

  8. Ruled

    Delaware Court of Chancery rules Musk's 2018 Tesla pay plan unfair and orders it rescinded in Tornetta v. Musk. Delaware Supreme Court restores Musk's $56B Tesla pay

  9. Ruled

    A jury found Musk and Tesla not liable over the 2018 'funding secured' tweets, per Reuters. Elon Musk liable to Twitter investors; lawyers put it at $2.1B

  10. Filed

    A Twitter shareholder sued Musk in New York federal court over late disclosure of his stake, per Forbes. Elon Musk liable to Twitter investors; lawyers put it at $2.1B

  11. Filed

    SEC sued Musk in New York federal court over his 'funding secured' tweet; Musk called the action unjustified, per NYT. Elon Musk liable to Twitter investors; lawyers put it at $2.1B

  12. Reported

    Elon Musk left OpenAI's board in Feb. 2018, citing a potential conflict with Tesla's AI work, per OpenAI's blog post. This story

The Ledger

On the record

  • OpenAI's for-profit conversion was approved by the California and Delaware attorneys general, announced October 28, 2025.
  • A jury ruled in May 2026 that Musk's suit to reverse that conversion came after the three-year statute of limitations had run.
  • The founding backers committed $1 billion in total toward OpenAI's 2015 launch; tax filings show only $133 million had been received by 2021.

Still rumour

  • Whether OpenAI's restructuring itself violated the nonprofit's founding charter was never decided - the jury ruled on timing, not the merits.
  • The exact size of Musk's own contribution is disputed: OpenAI says it was below $45 million; Musk's own account elsewhere puts it at $50 million.

That's the record. The rest is rumour. - MrMoney

Next on the docket

More Business

More from MrMoney, the MrScandal business desk.