⚖️ Live Nation, Ticketmaster: jury finds $1.72 ticket overcharge
Live Nation says the award covers about 20% of tickets and will appeal. Damages and remedies are still for the judge to set. ⏳
By MrMoney, business desk · Desk editor Laima Ērkšķe-Kreicberga · · 6 min read
ON RECORDPhoto: Coolcaesar · CC BY 4.0What we know
- A federal jury in Manhattan found on April 15, 2026 that Live Nation and Ticketmaster operated as a monopoly and overcharged ticket buyers, in a case brought by 33 states and Washington, D.C., NPR reported.
- The jury put the overcharge at $1.72 per ticket. Judge Arun Subramanian will set the overall damages and the remedies, The New York Times reported.
- Live Nation says the $1.72 applies to tickets at 257 venues, about 20% of total tickets, puts the aggregate single damages figure below $150 million, and says it will appeal unfavorable rulings.
- Earlier, the Justice Department settled its own case in March 2026. Live Nation said the settlement resolves all remaining matters with the DOJ without any admission of wrongdoing, and told NBC News it had already accrued $280 million toward state claims.
The fee fights over Live Nation and Ticketmaster did not start with a jury. They sit on a paper trail that runs from a class action filed in 2003 to an April 2026 verdict. Below, each action in order, with the amount, the ruling or the settlement, and what the company said.
2010 to 2020: the merger and the early fee settlements
January 2010: Justice Department clears the merger, with conditions
The Justice Department approved the Ticketmaster-Live Nation merger, a deal the Los Angeles Times put at $889 million. Ticketmaster had to divest its Paciolan subsidiary and license its ticketing software to rival AEG. The combined company also accepted 10 years of anti-retaliation provisions, The New York Times reported. Consumer groups said at the time that the conditions were only as tough as their enforcement.
See the receipt (opens in a new tab)January 2011: a $22.3 million charge for a 2003 fee class action
Live Nation disclosed in an SEC filing a $22.3 million charge tied to a class action filed in 2003, Billboard reported. The suit claimed Ticketmaster had misled buyers by describing processing and delivery charges as pass-through fees rather than profit generators. The filing said the case was settled in December 2010, subject to court approval.
See the receipt (opens in a new tab)By the numbers
- 16y 3mfrom first to latest entry on record
- 13receipts behind this story
May 2013: up to $23 million over a $9-a-month rewards program
The Associated Press reported that Ticketmaster agreed to settle claims for up to $23 million. The suit covered a rewards program that cost $9 a month and, plaintiffs said, gave no benefits. About 1.12 million people were eligible to claim up to $30 each. Plaintiffs said affected customers paid about $85 million, and that it took the average person about eight months to cancel. The defendants said the program disclosed its terms, and the settlement does not admit wrongdoing.
See the receipt (opens in a new tab)January 2020: six alleged decree violations, a $3 million enforcement bill
TicketNews reported that the Justice Department detailed six instances in which, it said, Live Nation executives retaliated against or threatened venues in breach of the 2010 consent decree. Live Nation settled. It agreed to cover the DOJ's $3 million enforcement costs and to a five-and-a-half-year extension of the decree, with a $1 million penalty for each future violation. A company representative said it strongly disagreed with the DOJ's allegations.
See the receipt (opens in a new tab)2023 to 2025: arbitration, the DOJ suit and the junk fee rule
August 2023 and October 2024: the arbitration bid fails twice
U.S. District Judge George Wu in Los Angeles refused to force ticket buyers into a mass arbitration process, Reuters reported, saying its rules posed a serious risk of being fundamentally unfair. In October 2024, Bloomberg Law reported, the Ninth Circuit affirmed that ruling, holding the arbitration clause unconscionable and unenforceable under California law. Live Nation has denied any liability in the underlying price suit.
See the receipt (opens in a new tab)May 2024: the Justice Department sues to break up Live Nation
The DOJ sued in the Southern District of New York, joined by 29 states and the District of Columbia, accusing Live Nation of violating the Sherman Act. Ten more states joined in August 2024, bringing the co-plaintiffs to 40, per the DOJ. The complaint called the add-on charges a Ticketmaster tax. Live Nation called the monopoly allegation absurd and said artists and venues, not it, set prices and keep most fees.
See the receipt (opens in a new tab)May 2025: all-in pricing arrives the day the FTC rule does
Engadget reported that Ticketmaster announced up-front pricing, fees included, on May 12, 2025. That was the same day the FTC's junk fees rule took effect requiring live event ticket sellers to show the full price. Engadget noted that the announcement did not mention the rule.
See the receipt (opens in a new tab)September 2025: the FTC and seven states sue over resale and price disclosure
The FTC and seven states sued in California. They allege Ticketmaster ignored brokers' breaches of ticket limits and reaped $3.7 billion in resale fees between 2019 and 2024. They also allege it failed to disclose full prices up front, Reuters reported. Reuters said representatives for the companies did not immediately respond to requests for comment. In the DOJ case, it noted, the companies have denied the allegations.
See the receipt (opens in a new tab)2026: a settlement, then a verdict
March 2026: the DOJ settles days into trial
NPR reported a $280 million settlement between the Justice Department, several states and Live Nation, with service fees capped at certain amphitheaters. NBC News reported the deal required Ticketmaster to divest up to 13 amphitheaters and cap ticketing service fees at 15%. Live Nation said the settlement resolves all remaining matters with the DOJ without any admission of wrongdoing. The head of the National Independent Venue Association told NPR it was not significant enough to call a slap on the wrist.
See the receipt (opens in a new tab)April 15, 2026: the jury sides with 33 states and D.C.
After four days of deliberations, the jury found that Live Nation and Ticketmaster operated as a monopoly that harmed consumers, NPR reported. It put the overcharge at $1.72 per ticket. Live Nation said the verdict is not the last word, pointing to pending motions that will decide whether the liability and damages rulings stand. It also said it would appeal any unfavorable rulings. CEO Michael Rapino denied anticompetitive practices in testimony.
See the receipt (opens in a new tab)"Robbing them, blind, baby, that's how we do"
A Live Nation regional employee, in messages shown at trial, as quoted by The Hollywood Reporter
Rapino disavowed that exchange on the stand, saying it was disgusting and not the way the company operates, The Hollywood Reporter reported.
The amounts, side by side
| Date | Action | Amount on record | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 2011 | Fee class action filed 2003 | $22.3 million charge | Settled Dec 2010, per SEC filing |
| May 2013 | Rewards-program class action | Up to $23 million | Settled, no admission of wrongdoing |
| Jan 2020 | DOJ consent decree violations | $3 million enforcement costs | Settled, decree extended |
| Mar 2026 | DOJ antitrust case | $280 million | Settled, no admission of wrongdoing |
| Apr 2026 | States' antitrust case | $1.72 per ticket | Jury liability finding, remedies pending |
The $22.3 million and $23 million are different cases with different figures and should not be added together. The $280 million is the figure NPR reports for the March settlement. Live Nation separately says it has accrued the same amount toward state claims. MrMoney keeps the columns apart.
Quick quiz · 3 questions
Earlier on file: Biggest Ticketmaster fee settlements: $400M tentative credit
The Live Nation Entertainment file
- Ruled
NYT reported a federal jury found Live Nation a monopoly and Ticketmaster overcharged by $1.72 a ticket; Live Nation says it will appeal. Biggest Ticketmaster fee settlements: $400M tentative credit
- Ruled
Federal jury found monopoly and a $1.72 per-ticket overcharge; Live Nation said it will appeal, per NPR. This story
- Reported
DOJ settled its case; Live Nation said no admission of wrongdoing, per NBC News. This story
- Filed
Justice Department and states sued, alleging Sherman Act violations; Live Nation called the claims absurd, per CNBC. This story
- Reported
Settled DOJ consent decree claims, paying $3 million in enforcement costs; decree extended, per TicketNews. This story
- Filed
Billboard reported Live Nation disclosed a $22.3M charge tied to a 2003 fee class action, subject to court approval. Biggest Ticketmaster fee settlements: $400M tentative credit
- Ruled
Justice Department announced conditions for approving the Ticketmaster-Live Nation merger, per The New York Times. This story
On file: The Live Nation Entertainment file · The Ticketmaster file
The Ledger
On the record
- A federal jury found on April 15, 2026 that Live Nation and Ticketmaster operated as a monopoly and put the overcharge at $1.72 per ticket. The DOJ settled separately in March 2026 without any admission of wrongdoing, per Live Nation.
Still rumour
- The overall damages figure and the remedies, including any breakup, are not set in the documents read. Live Nation says it will appeal.
- The FTC rental-fee settlement named in today's peg, and the contents of Live Nation's SEC filings of Nov. 4 and 5, 2026, are not confirmed in the documents read.
That's the record. The rest is rumour. - MrMoney
Next on the docket
More Business
Business · 💸 Biggest Ticketmaster fee settlements: $400M tentative credit
WSJ reported a tentative $400M credit for 50M buyers; a Buffalo News column put the voucher pot at $10M. Cash deals run far smaller. ⏳
Business · ⚖️ Amazon Ring: FTC order seeks $5.8M over employee video access
The FTC says Ring let staff view customer videos; Ring denies breaking the law, and a judge's sign-off is unconfirmed.
Business · ⚖️ Nvidia China chip smuggling cases: $2.5B alleged, 9 charged
Taiwan charged nine over forged papers; the US alleges $2.5B in servers. Supermicro says it is not a target; no verdict is on record. ⏳
PENDINGPhoto: Zachary Caraway · Pexels License⚖️ Jensen Huang faces subpoena threat from House China committee
Rep. Moolenaar says Huang has until end of Wednesday to answer a briefing request. No public reply was found in the reports read. ⏳