⚾ A-Rod dropped his suits after a 162-game ban cost him $25M

In 2014 he said he never used banned substances; the Miami Herald later reported a DEA summary says he told federal agents otherwise. 🗣️

Alex RodriguezDROPPEDPhoto: A-Rod Damon.jpg: Keith Allison derivative work: Inefable001 (talk) · CC BY-SA 2.0

Photo: A-Rod Damon.jpg: Keith Allison derivative work: Inefable001 (talk), CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Desaturated and cropped by MrScandal.

What we know

  • MLB announced a 211-game suspension on Aug. 5, 2013, citing Rodriguez's use and possession of testosterone and human growth hormone and an effort to obstruct its investigation; arbitrator Fredric Horowitz cut it to 162 games on Jan. 11, 2014 (ESPN).
  • On Feb. 7, 2014, Rodriguez's lawyer filed a notice of voluntary dismissal of his tortious-interference suit against MLB and of his suits against then-commissioner Bud Selig and the players' union, ESPN reported.
  • ESPN reported Rodriguez was losing $25 million in salary during the suspension; the $27.5 million figure is the Yankees' yearly luxury-tax charge on his $275 million contract.
  • Rodriguez said in a January 2014 statement that he did not use performance-enhancing substances as alleged; MLB defended the original 211-game ban.
  • The Miami Herald reported in November 2014, citing a DEA report it reviewed, that Rodriguez told federal agents on Jan. 29 that he bought banned drugs from Anthony Bosch; his lawyer declined to comment.

Alex Rodriguez quit the courtroom fight on a Friday. On Feb. 7, 2014, his lawyer Joseph Tacopina confirmed to ESPN that a notice of voluntary dismissal had been filed in federal court in Manhattan. It ended Rodriguez's lawsuit against Major League Baseball for tortious interference, and his suits against then-commissioner Bud Selig and the players' union, ESPN reported. No explanation was given.

The scoreboard: a 211-game suspension trimmed to 162, a salary loss ESPN put at $25 million, and a legal campaign that ended in a dismissal notice. Rodriguez has said he did not use banned substances. MLB defended the ban. MrMuscles has the filings and the statements; here is how the game went.

The ban

MLB announced the suspension on Aug. 5, 2013. Its statement said the discipline rested on Rodriguez's "use and possession of numerous forms of prohibited performance-enhancing substances, including testosterone and human growth hormone, over the course of multiple years," plus a course of conduct meant to obstruct the commissioner's investigation. The case was not built on a failed drug test, the New York Times reported; MLB officials believed documents and witness accounts were enough. Rodriguez was allowed to keep playing while he appealed.

On Jan. 11, 2014, arbitrator Fredric Horowitz cut the ban from 211 games to 162, which covered the whole 2014 season and any playoff games, ESPN reported. Rodriguez's side called the ruling "inconsistent" and said it rested on "false and wholly unreliable testimony." Rodriguez said in a statement that he did not use performance-enhancing substances as alleged and would take the fight to federal court. MLB said it believed the original 211 games were appropriate but respected the panel's decision.

"The number of games sadly comes as no surprise, as the deck has been stacked against me from day one."

Alex Rodriguez, statement on the arbitrator's ruling, as reported by ESPN, Jan. 11, 2014

The money

ESPN reported that Rodriguez was losing $25 million in salary during the suspension. Before the ruling the exposure was reported as higher: about $34 million over the full 211 games (Yahoo Sports) and nearly $33 million (ESPN), with ESPN noting each game shaved off the penalty would save him $154,000.

The $27.5 million figure that attaches to this story is a different number. Per ESPN, it is one-tenth of the $275 million contract, the amount the Yankees are charged yearly for luxury-tax purposes. With the ban set at 162 games, ESPN put the team's luxury-tax relief at about $24.1 million. The Yankees still owed Rodriguez about $61 million for 2015 through 2017.

The lawsuits

The legal theory was floating around before the ban was even final. The New York Times reported in August 2013 that his legal team had discussed a federal suit claiming the Yankees and MLB worked together so the team could escape the rest of his contract. The Yankees said in a statement that they did not direct MLB's investigation or use it to avoid their obligations under his contract. After Tacopina alleged the club mishandled his hip care, ESPN reported that Yankees president Randy Levine and the team denied the allegations and MLB denied the accusations of a conspiracy.

The timing was set by the court. U.S. District Judge Edgardo Ramos told Rodriguez's lawyers on Jan. 30 to respond by that Friday to arguments from MLB and the union that the case should be dismissed, ESPN reported. They filed the dismissal instead. Tacopina told the Associated Press that the earlier statements "say everything that needs to be said." Rodriguez was in Miami and made no public remarks that day.

Why he walked is reporting, not record. Sources told ESPNNewYork.com that the anticipated $10 million in legal fees weighed on him and that he wanted to repair relations with baseball so he could keep working in the sport after his playing days. Those are unnamed-source claims, and Rodriguez's side gave no explanation on the day.

"We have been informed that Alex Rodriguez has reached the prudent decision to end all of the litigation related to the Biogenesis matter."

Major League Baseball statement, as reported by ESPN, Feb. 7, 2014

The players' union, which Rodriguez had also sued, said in its own statement that withdrawing was the right thing to do and that his decision to move forward was in everyone's best interest. One suit survived: his claim in New York state court against Yankees physician Christopher Ahmad and New York-Presbyterian Hospital, alleging they mishandled his care during the 2012 playoffs.

The timeline footnote

In November 2014 the Miami Herald reported on a 15-page synopsis of a Jan. 29 meeting between Rodriguez, federal agents and prosecutors. According to the DEA report as the Herald described it, Rodriguez said he bought banned substances from Biogenesis owner Anthony Bosch, paying roughly $12,000 a month over about two years, and received immunity from prosecution in exchange. The Herald noted that meeting took place less than three weeks after the arbitrator's ruling and his public statement that he did not use performance-enhancing substances. The lawsuits were dropped on Feb. 7.

Tacopina, who attended the meeting, declined to comment to the Herald, citing grand jury secrecy. When New York magazine's Intelligencer reported on the Herald story, it quoted him: "He didn't get indicted." And then, per the same report: "It's over. Game. Set. Match." The documents read here do not include any Rodriguez comment on the DEA summary.

Quick quiz · 3 questions

  1. On the record or still rumour?MLB suspended Rodriguez for 211 games in August 2013, an arbitrator cut it to 162 in January 2014, and a notice of voluntary dismissal ended his suits against MLB, Selig and the union on Feb. 7, 2014; ESPN put his lost salary at $25 million.
  2. On the record or still rumour?The Herald's account of the DEA summary is not matched by any Rodriguez comment in the documents read, and the outcome of his remaining suit over his medical care is not in them either.
  3. Which year?MLB suspends Rodriguez for 211 games over PED use and obstruction; he said he would appeal

More games on the record: Price Tag · Timeline

By the numbers

  • 5 yrsfrom first to latest entry on recordFeb 2009 to Feb 2014, 5 dated entries in the file
  • 7receipts behind this story7 news reports, 2013 to 2014
  • #3in biggest punishments in sportAlex Rodriguez: Biogenesis doping suspension, 2013. Scandal Score 87 of 100

Counted by MrScandal from the receipts, the Files and our rankings.

Earlier on file: Joe West, 4 umpires sue MLB pension plan over $2M+ in benefits · Biggest punishments in sport: Armstrong's stripped titles lead · Biggest sports punishments: Astros' $5M fine, two firings top

The Alex Rodriguez file

Last entry Feb 7, 2014
  1. Filed

    Notice of voluntary dismissal filed in his suit against MLB and in his suits against Selig and the players' union. This story

  2. Reported

    Per the Miami Herald, a DEA report says he told federal agents he bought banned drugs from Bosch; his lawyer declined comment. This story

  3. Ruled

    Arbitrator Fredric Horowitz reduced the suspension from 211 games to 162, covering the 2014 season and any playoff games. This story

  4. Ruled

    MLB suspends Rodriguez for 211 games over PED use and obstruction; he said he would appeal. Biggest punishments in sport: Armstrong's stripped titles lead

  5. Admitted

    Rodriguez told ESPN he took a banned substance while with the Texas Rangers. Biggest sports punishments: Astros' $5M fine, two firings top

The Ledger

On the record

  • MLB suspended Rodriguez for 211 games in August 2013, an arbitrator cut it to 162 in January 2014, and a notice of voluntary dismissal ended his suits against MLB, Selig and the union on Feb. 7, 2014; ESPN put his lost salary at $25 million.

Still rumour

  • Why he dropped the suits: the $10 million legal-fee and reconciliation reasons come from unnamed sources, and his lawyer gave no explanation.
  • The Herald's account of the DEA summary is not matched by any Rodriguez comment in the documents read, and the outcome of his remaining suit over his medical care is not in them either.

That's the record. The rest is rumour. - MrMuscles

Next on the docket

More Sports

More from MrMuscles, the MrScandal sports desk.